hig.sePublications
Change search
ExportLink to record
Permanent link

Direct link
BETA

Project

Project type/Form of grant
Project grant
Title [sv]
Rektors arbete och lämplighetsprövning av nya lärare. En studie av rektorers förändrade arbetsvillkor efter införandet av lärarlegitimation
Abstract [sv]
Sammanfattning:När lärarlegitimationen infördes fick rektorerna nya arbetsuppgifter, bland annat lämplighetsprövning av nya lärare. Redan innan hade de tuffa arbetsförhållanden. Projektet har undersökt hur bland annat lämplighetsprövningen påverkar rektorernas yrkesroll, arbetsvillkor och arbetsmiljö. Den kunskapen kan ge bättre arbetsförhållanden och bidra till färre sjukskrivningar. Syfte:Projektet skulle studera hur införandet av lärarlegitimation med introduktionsår för lärare påverkar rektorers arbetsvillkor, kompetens och yrkesroll samt hur rektorerna hanterar den nya arbetssituationen. Den nya bedömningsuppgiften skulle studeras i ljuset av rektorernas samlade arbetsuppgifter och totala arbetsvillkor. Genomförande:Studien omfattade rektorer inom grundskolan. Forskarna gjorde en fallstudie i två kommuner och skickade ut enkäter till rektorer i 24 kommuner, små och stora, i både städer och på landsbygd. De fick in 249 svar av 646 tillfrågade rektorer.Intervjuerna tog bland annat upp rektorernas farhågor, hur svåra de tycker att de nya arbetsuppgifterna är, hur deras yrkesroll påverkas och vad det innebär för relationen med personalen. Samtidigt genomfördes observationer i skolmiljön.Några intervjuer genomfördes i samband med att rektorer gjorde klassrumsobservation inför en lämplighetsbedömning. De följdes upp med ytterligare intervju efter prövningen. Frågorna till enkäten grundades på intervjuer, observationer och dokument (policydokument, stöd för lämplighetsprövningen och introduktionsåret med flera). Resultat: kommunernas organisation och styrsystem innebar olika förutsättningar för rektorerna att hantera de nya arbetsuppgifterna. Lämplighetsprövningen försämrade inte deras sociala relationer på skolan och de fick stöd i den av mentorerna. Den förändrade deras ledarskap på olika sätt, det var rill exempel en arbetsuppgift de inte kunde delegera. Lämplighetsprövningen togs bort 2014. Studien ger förståelse för hur den nya reformen påverkade rektorernas position, arbetsinnehåll, relationer, arbetsvillkor och arbetsmiljö. Den kunskapen kan stärka rektorerna som ledare, skapa bättre arbetsförhållanden och bidra till att minska höga sjuktal. Resultaten publiceras på en särskild hemsida och sprids via pressmeddelanden. Dessutom presenteras de i en populärvetenskaplig bok, artiklar i fackförbundstidningar samt via vetenskaplig publicering och vetenskapliga konferenser.
Publications (8 of 8) Show all publications
Fransson, G., Frelin, A. & Grannäs, J. (2017). Exploring a conceptual framework to understand how principals balance the partly contradictory tasks of evaluating and supporting newly qualified teachers. In: : . Paper presented at The European Conference on Educational Research (ECER2017), 22-25 August 2017, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Open this publication in new window or tab >>Exploring a conceptual framework to understand how principals balance the partly contradictory tasks of evaluating and supporting newly qualified teachers
2017 (English)Conference paper, Oral presentation only (Refereed)
Abstract [en]

In many countries it is argued that the “quality of teachers” is the most important school-related factor in pupils’ learning (Hattie, 2009; 2012). Teacher quality has become a key argument for teachers’ professional development. When it comes to newly qualified teachers (NQTs), in many countries the call for “teacher quality” has either led to reforms that support NQTs or reforms requiring an evaluation of their competence. In some countries these approaches are combined, with induction systems and mentoring that support NQTs and an evaluation of their skills to ensure quality. However, some research suggests that if the same person performs both roles it is more difficult to create and maintain a relationship based on confidence, openness and mutual trust that promotes risk-free learning (Author 1, 201*, Jones 2009). In some countries or states mentors perform both these roles (cf. Yusko & Feiman Nemser, 2008), whereas in others these two roles are separated so that mentors support and principals evaluate.

The latter kind of system was introduced in Sweden in 2011, with mentors supporting NQTs and principals performing the evaluation (Government Bill, 2010/11). However, previous research shows that when the Swedish principals performed the assessment they also supported the NQTs (Author 1, Author 2, Author 3, 201*) in that they partly applied an instructional leadership (cf. REF) and gave post-observation feedback. However, being both an evaluator and supervisor can be challenging. For instance, Hinchey (2010) claims that teachers only improve their practice in relatively non-threatening contexts and that the assessment may challenge this (cf. Author 1, 201*; Range, Young & Hvidstone, 2013).

A review of the research literature reveals that there is an urgent need for theoretical development in order to understand how principals enact and balance their roles as evaluators of NQTs and pedagogical leaders. In responding to this call, the purpose of the paper is: (a) to elaborate and discuss a conceptual framework that captures how principals enact and balance their roles as evaluators and pedagogical leaders in the context of evaluating NQTs and (b) to exemplify how data can be related to the framework.

Theoretical framework

The emphasis on and combination of supportive and evaluative dimensions are contained in the framework of a four-way table that includes “formal and structured evaluation” vs. “informal evaluation” and  “strong instructional leadership” vs. “weak instructional leadership”.

The evaluation dimension is defined as the extent to which evaluations are scheduled, planned, directed by guiding formulae, how the different issues of the national standards are focused, time spent on the evaluation, the structure and focus of the follow-up discussions etc.   

The instructional dimension is defined as how and how much guidance is given and how the NQTs professional development are facilitated. Here the focus is on guidance and feedback that contribute to developing the instructional skills or pedagogical thinking of the NQT. Positive feedback relates to the content included in the table. Positive feedback in a general sense, without connection to instruction, thinking or a situation, is not included. For instance, positive feedback heard in the corridor, such as: ‘colleagues say you perform well’, is not included in this dimension. Guidance can be absent or present, more or less extensive, or constructive and detailed.

Methods/methodology

The framework is developed by reviewing the research literature in the areas of teacher induction (cf. (Hobson, Ashby, Malderez, & Tomlinson, 2009), evaluation of NQTs (cf. Yusko & Feiman Nemser, 2008) and principals’ instructional leadership (cf. Neumerski, 2013; LaPointe Terosky, 2016). Most of the literature relating to principals’ instructional leadership focuses on teachers in general and not specifically NQTs (cf. Tuytens & Devos, 2017), but is nevertheless valuable.

Drawing on and combining supportive and evaluative dimensions result in a four-way table framework with the following axes:  “formal and structured evaluation” vs. “informal evaluation” and “strong instructional leadership” vs. “weak instructional leadership”.

This framework is then used in explorative analyses of data from a longitudinal research project in which five principals conducting a formal evaluation of NQTs are followed in the year of the evaluation. These five principals are regarded as cases. The NQTs being evaluated teach Years 4-6.

Each principal is interviewed at least twice during the year (in total between 73-158 minutes), which forms the main data for the analysis. The interviews and analysis explore principals’ self-reported information regarding their strategies to enact and balance their role as evaluators and the support they provide. Using the software NVivo, codes are created based on content analysis (Miles, Huberman & Saldaña, 2014).

Self-reported data needs to be looked at critically (Podsakoff, MacKenzie, Lee, & Podsakoff, 2003). To validate this kind of data: (i) observations and recordings of post-observation conversations (tot. 72 minutes) are performed with two of the principals (A and C) and their NQTs, (ii) joint interviews are conducted with three principals (A, C and E) and their NQTs (in total 130 minutes) and (iii) observations of three of the principals’ observations (B, C, D) are carried out. A coherent design of these validating strategies is not possible due to ethical and practical reasons. Three of the NQTs did not feel comfortable with the participation of an external researcher during the observations and/or post-observation conversations. Some of the planned observations were cancelled due to illness, the unavailability of the informant or were performed ad hoc and informally and were not observed or recorded.

Expected outcomes/results

Positioning the principals in the framework of the four-way table with the axes “formal and structured evaluation” vs. “informal evaluation” and “strong instructional leadership” vs. “weak instructional leadership” enables their actions to be positioned differently. Four out of the five teachers are positioned more towards “strong instructional leadership” and “formal and structured evaluation”, albeit with different emphases on the two dimensions. The fifth principal (E) is positioned more towards “informal evaluation” and “weak instructional leadership”. This principal describes his/her leadership as ‘leadership on the run’.

The overall conclusion is that the theoretical framework enables principals to be positioned according to how their evaluative and supportive roles vary. Also, the quality of the data, for instance with regard to quantity, focus on relevant issues and different kinds of data (e.g. self-reported narratives, narratives from other actors such as NQTs, and first-hand information from the researchers’ direct observations) gives a much more informed analysis of the positioning in the framework. However, in this small-scale study, the different kinds of data do not contradict each other, but strengthen the conclusions and the positioning.

Thus, the framework facilitates an understanding of how principals facilitate NQTs professional development in a context in which evaluative and supportive dimensions are applied. The framework could also be used to analyse how mentors balance the supportive and evaluative dimensions.

References

Author 1 (201*). [details removed for peer review]. Article published in international peer-reviewed journal.

Author 1, Author 2 & Author 3 (201*). [details removed for peer review]. Paper presented at an International Annual Conference.

Government bill 2010/11:20 Legitimation för lärare och förskollärare [Registration for Teachers and Pre-School Teachers]. The Swedish Government.

 Hattie, J. 2009. Visible learning: a synthesis of over 800 meta-analyses relating to achievement. London: New York: Routledge.

Hattie, J. (2012). Visible learning for teachers: maximizing impact on learning. London: Routledge.

Hinchey, P.H. (2010). Getting teacher assessment right: What policymakers can learn from research. Boulder, CO: National Education Policy Center.

Hobson, A. J., Ashby, P., Malderez, A., & Tomlinson, P. D. (2009). Mentoring beginning teachers: what we know and what we don't. Teaching and Teacher Education, 25(1), 207-216.

Jones, M. (2009). Supporting the supporters of novice teachers: An analysis of mentors’ needs from twelve European countries presented from an English perspective. Research in Comparative and International Education 4, no. 1: 4–21.

LaPointe Terosky, A. (2016): Enacting instructional leadership: perspectives and actions of public K-12 principals, School Leadership & Management,

Miles, M.B., Huberman, A.M. & Saldaña, J. (2014). Qualitative data analysis: a methods sourcebook. (3. ed.) Los Angeles: Sage.

Neumerski, C. M. (2013). Rethinking Instructional Leadership: A Review of What Do We Know About Principal, Teacher, and Coach Instructional Leadership, and Where Should We Go from Here? Educational Administration Quarterly 49 (2): 310–347.

Podsakoff, P. M., MacKenzie, S. B., Lee, J.-Y., & Podsakoff, N. P. (2003). Common method biases in behavioral research: A critical review of the literature and recommended remedies. Journal of Applied Psychology, 88, 879–903. 

Range, B. G., Young, S. & Hvidston, D. (2013) Teacher perceptions about observation conferences: what do teachers think about their formative supervision in one US school district?, School Leadership & Management, 33:1, 61-77.

Tuytens, M. & Devos, G. (2017) The role of feedback from the school

leader during teacher evaluation for teacher and school improvement, Teachers and Teaching, 23:1, 6-24,

Yusko, B., & Feiman Nemser. S. (2008). Embracing contraries: Combining assistance and assessment in new teacher induction. Teacher College Record 110, no. 5: 923–53.

National Category
Didactics
Research subject
Innovative Learning
Identifiers
urn:nbn:se:hig:diva-25228 (URN)
Conference
The European Conference on Educational Research (ECER2017), 22-25 August 2017, Copenhagen, Denmark
Funder
AFA Insurance, 120292
Available from: 2017-09-13 Created: 2017-09-13 Last updated: 2025-10-02Bibliographically approved
Fransson, G., Frelin, A. & Grannäs, J. (2017). Rektorer och lämplighetsprövningen av nyutbildade lärare: En rapport från forskningsprojektet Rektors arbete och lämplighetsprövning av nya lärare: En studie av rektorers förändrade arbetsvillkor efter införandet av lärarlegitimation. Gävle: Gävle University Press
Open this publication in new window or tab >>Rektorer och lämplighetsprövningen av nyutbildade lärare: En rapport från forskningsprojektet Rektors arbete och lämplighetsprövning av nya lärare: En studie av rektorers förändrade arbetsvillkor efter införandet av lärarlegitimation
2017 (Swedish)Report (Other academic)
Abstract [sv]

Den 2 mars 2011 beslutade riksdagen att införa en legitimation för lärare och förskollärare samt att nyexaminerade lärare och förskollärare skulle genomgå en introduktionsperiod. Under denna introduktionsperiod skulle de få stöd av en mentor samtidigt som rektor eller förskolechef skulle bedöma deras lämplighet för yrket.

För rektorerna innebär lämplighetsprövningen av nyexaminerade lärare nya arbetsuppgifter och ett formaliserat uppdrag att bedöma lärares skicklighet. Detta i samband med att rektorers arbetssituation har befunnits vara intensiv med en uppsplittrad vardag där många snabba beslut måste tas väcker frågor kring hur arbetets förutsättningar påverkar lämplighetsprövningen, och hur lämplighetsprövningen påverkar arbetsförhållanden och yrkesroller.

I juni månad 2014 inbjöds 646 rektorer att besvara en enkät rörande lämplighetsprövningen. 248 rektorer svarade vilket ger en svarsfrekvens på 39 % (n=248). 159 kvinnor (64 %) och 89 män (36 %) besvarade enkäten. Nästan 60 % av rektorerna hade varit rektor på sin nuvarande enhet i tre år eller mindre. 77 % av rektorerna var verksamma vid kommunala skolor medan 23 % var verksamma vid fristående skolor.

Resultaten visar att rektorernas upplevelse av lämplighetsprövningen är att den i huvudsak, om än i varierade grad, upplevts meningsfull och att rektorerna känt sig tillfreds med de lämplighetsprövningar de genomfört. Det förekommer mer spriddaåsikter om i vilken mån lämplighetsprövningen varit väl investerad tid och kraft. Lämplighetsprövningen har konkurrerat med många andra arbetsuppgifter men det finns ändå en tendens att rektorerna som grupp anser att den investerade tiden och kraften varit värt utfallet.

Det råder oenighet kring i vilken mån lämplighetsprövningen bidragit till mer positiva relationer mellan rektor och den nya läraren, men att det råder relativt stor enighet om att lämplighetsprövningen inte nämnvärt försämrat relationerna. En sammantagen tolkning av detta är att något mer positiva relationer med de nya lärarna etablerats och att båda parter lärt känna varandra såväl professionellt som privat. Endast 12 % av rektorerna anger att de har fått någon utbildning i att genomföra lämplighetsprövningen. Rektorerna har haft ett begränsat stöd av huvudman eller andra rektorer vilket skapat ett frirum att genomföra lämplighetsprövningen på sitt eget sätt. Samtalen med mentorn har varit viktiga för rektorns bedömning. Vidare framträder lärarkollegiets informella bedömning dels som en viktig komponent i rektors formella bedömning, dels som ett viktig komplement till i rektors formella bedömning. Av de 137 lämplighetsprövningar som genomförts rådde viss tveksamhet i 10 fall och i två fall uppgav rektorerna att det råddestor tveksamhet. Samtliga 137 lärare bedömdes dock efter introduktionsperiodens slutsom lämpliga.

Rektorers tilltro till politiker har påverkats negativt av alla turer kring lärarlegitimationen och att lämplighetsprövningen slutligen avvecklades. 73 % av rektorerna anser att deras förtroende för politiker minskat, medan 6 % anser att förtroendet ökat.

Place, publisher, year, edition, pages
Gävle: Gävle University Press, 2017. p. 56
Series
RD-report, ISSN 1403-8749 ; 45
Keywords
Arbetsmiljö, introduktionsperiod, lärare, lämplighetsprövning, lärarlegitimation, mentor, rektor, skola, skolledare
National Category
Educational Sciences
Identifiers
urn:nbn:se:hig:diva-23825 (URN)
Available from: 2017-08-10 Created: 2017-08-10 Last updated: 2025-11-21Bibliographically approved
Grannäs, J., Fransson, G. & Frelin, A. (2016). Principals’ assessments of NQTs’ competences: The use of informal and interpersonal sources of information for assessment. In: 2016 annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association: . Paper presented at The American Educational Research Association (AERA) annual meeting, 8-12 April, 2016, Washington, USA.
Open this publication in new window or tab >>Principals’ assessments of NQTs’ competences: The use of informal and interpersonal sources of information for assessment
2016 (English)In: 2016 annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, 2016Conference paper, Published paper (Refereed)
Abstract [en]

This paper analyzes and discusses the informal assessments of newly qualified teachers (NQTs) that are performed in relation to the mandatory formal assessment outlined in the recently introduced teacher registration reform in Sweden (TRR). Questionnaire data was collected in three municipality clusters. 11 semi-structured interviews with principals were conducted in two municipalities. These were analyzed to determine whether and how principals used informal and interpersonal sources of information about NQTs’ competences. The school culture, together with the use of formal and informal assessment, influences a principal’s final assessment of an NQT. The use of informal and interpersonal sources of information for assessment fit the school context in ways that a standardized reform cannot match.

Keywords
assessment, NQT, principals, school culture, school reform
National Category
Didactics
Identifiers
urn:nbn:se:hig:diva-20667 (URN)
Conference
The American Educational Research Association (AERA) annual meeting, 8-12 April, 2016, Washington, USA
Funder
AFA Insurance
Note

Paper published in the AERA Online Paper Repository http://www.aera.net/Publications/Online-Paper-Repository/AERA-Online-Paper-Repository

Available from: 2015-11-25 Created: 2015-11-25 Last updated: 2025-10-02Bibliographically approved
Frelin, A., Grannäs, J. & Fransson, G. (2016). Relational Dimensions of Policy Enactment: Principals' Experiences of Relations With Newly Qualified Teachers During the Teacher Registration Reform. In: : . Paper presented at 2016 AERA Annual meeting, "Public Scholarship to Educate Diverse Democracies", 8-12 April 2016, Washington DC.
Open this publication in new window or tab >>Relational Dimensions of Policy Enactment: Principals' Experiences of Relations With Newly Qualified Teachers During the Teacher Registration Reform
2016 (English)Conference paper, Poster (with or without abstract) (Refereed)
Abstract [en]

Globalized educational reforms include registration reforms for newly qualified teachers (NQTs). As policies travel, this paper examines the Swedish example of principals’ policy enactments (Ball et al, 2012) when assessing NQTs. Questionnaire data was collected in three municipality clusters. 11 semi-structured interviews with principals were conducted in two municipalities. These were analyzed to determine whether and how the relations between principals and NTQs changed due to the teacher registration reform. The results showed some positive change in the relations and that contrary to the reform’s intentions support and assessment practices were intermingled. As the complexity of the situation was underestimated, other countries may learn from the example of a reform that led to a policy retreat.

Keywords
certification/licensure, policy, principals
National Category
Educational Sciences
Identifiers
urn:nbn:se:hig:diva-20593 (URN)
Conference
2016 AERA Annual meeting, "Public Scholarship to Educate Diverse Democracies", 8-12 April 2016, Washington DC
Funder
AFA Insurance, 120292
Available from: 2015-11-14 Created: 2015-11-14 Last updated: 2025-10-02Bibliographically approved
Fransson, G. (2015). A Culture of Trust or an Ideology of Distrust?: Comparing Finnish and Swedish Educational Culture and the Impact on National Mentoring Approaches. In: F. Kochan, A. Kent & A. Green (Ed.), Uncovering the Cultural Dynamics in Mentoring Programs and Relationships: Enhancing Practice and Research (pp. 253-271). Charlotte, N. Carolina, USA: Information Age Publishing
Open this publication in new window or tab >>A Culture of Trust or an Ideology of Distrust?: Comparing Finnish and Swedish Educational Culture and the Impact on National Mentoring Approaches
2015 (English)In: Uncovering the Cultural Dynamics in Mentoring Programs and Relationships: Enhancing Practice and Research / [ed] F. Kochan, A. Kent & A. Green, Charlotte, N. Carolina, USA: Information Age Publishing, 2015, p. 253-271Chapter in book (Refereed)
Place, publisher, year, edition, pages
Charlotte, N. Carolina, USA: Information Age Publishing, 2015
Series
Perspectives on Mentoring
Keywords
Comparative research, culture, Finland, induction, mentoring, newly qualified teachers, policy, Sweden.
National Category
Educational Sciences
Identifiers
urn:nbn:se:hig:diva-15379 (URN)000354423500017 ()9781623968526 (ISBN)9781623968519 (ISBN)9781623968533 (ISBN)
Funder
AFA Insurance, dnr 120292
Available from: 2013-09-20 Created: 2013-09-20 Last updated: 2025-10-02Bibliographically approved
Fransson, G., Frelin, A. & Grannäs, J. (2015). Resources and Support for Principals’ Assessment of Newly Qualified Teachers During a Teacher Registration Reform. In: : . Paper presented at ECER 2015, The European Conference on Educational Research, 'Education and Transition - Contributions from Educational Research', 8-11 september 2015, Corvinus University, Budapest, Bulgarien (pp. 1076).
Open this publication in new window or tab >>Resources and Support for Principals’ Assessment of Newly Qualified Teachers During a Teacher Registration Reform
2015 (English)Conference paper, Oral presentation with published abstract (Refereed)
Abstract [sv]

In July 2011 a teacher registration reform (TRR) and a probation year for newly qualified teachers (NQTs) came into effect in Sweden (Government Bill, 2010/11).

It required newly qualified teachers and pre-school teachers to do a “probationary year” under the guidance of a mentor. Between July 1 2011 and July 1 2014 principals or pre-school managers were responsible for assessing whether the NQT were to be registered or not. The principals were expected to perform this assessment by following the national standards (competence profiles) developed by the Swedish National Agency for Education, the issuing authority. The purpose of this paper is to analyse and discuss (1) sources of support for assessment and (2) to what extent these supported the principals in the assessment of the NQTs. Data is drawn from a questionnaire answered by 248 principals, completed in 2014 within the research project “Head teachers working conditions and the evaluation of newly qualified teachers (the RAOL-project)”

The TRR is another example of travelling policies in a globalized world, in this case with origin in Scotland and Canada. Some contextual policy learning adjustments (Lingard, 2010; Waldow, 2009) were made regarding the standards, but almost no adjustments regarding the structure and focus of the reform. As a consequence, parts of the reforms have been adjusted or withdrawn at several occasions. One major policy retreat was made in June 2013 when the Minister of Education, the Presidents of two teacher unions, representatives of The Swedish Association of Local Authorities and Regions and The Swedish Association of Independent Schools made a joint statement to withdraw the assessment of NQTs. Hence, the implementation of the Swedish TRR and the assessment of NQTs can be viewed as an example of policy borrowing and the challenges encountered when reforms are implemented prior to a completed policy learning processes. From July2014 the assessment ceased to be part of principals’ task.

Thus, this paper offers unique data from a specific time period with particular tasks and working conditions for principals. Swedish research on how principals assess and evaluate teachers' skills is largely absent, but similar international research indicates the need to explore how such assessments are performed. For instance, Kimball & Milanowski (2009) found that head teachers vary their evaluations over time and in relation to subjective values, and that their evaluations seem to be based on intuition and instinct rather than carefully formulated and objective criteria.

Recent studies show that the working conditions for principals are intense with fragmented working days during which many quick decisions have to be made (Day, 2000; Nihlfors & Johansson, 2013).  Research on school leaders' working conditions (e.g. Swedish Work Environment Authority, 2011; Ludvigsson, 2009; Schools Inspectorate, 2010) raise questions on how working conditions affect the assessment of NQTs, and how the assessment affects working conditions and the principal’s role and self-image (Federici, 2013). Principals operate in the intersection of different interests, expectations, tasks and roles (Nihlfors & Johansson, 2013; Törnsén & Ärlestig, 2014), which affect the psychosocial work environment. Interestingly, changes in the professional role were being handled differently by the principals depending on their career stage (The Swedish Research Council, 2011).

Even though the main data reported here is Swedish, in times of policy travelling the results are of importance in a wider European perspective to help understand principals’ working condition and roles.

Methods (max 400 ord)

In June 2014, 644 principals were invited to answer a questionnaire and 249 responded, yielding a response rate of 38,5%. This may be considered relatively low, however, at this time it was generally known that the assessment would be phased out which probably reduced responsiveness. It should be noted that a similar questionnaire of principals conducted in December 2013 in another Swedish research project had a response rate of 31% (n = 106), wherein our response rate at a later stage can be considered relatively good.

Three clusters of principals representing different municipals located in different regions in Sweden were invited, selected to ensure a diverse sample. The web questionnaire was sent to all primary, secondary and upper-secondary schools in three regions: a metropolitan area (1 municipality), major regional centre (8 municipalities) and rural locations (15 municipalities).

The survey focused the following areas: school context, working conditions, assessment of the NQTs, support available for the principal, cooperation, the principals’ strategies in observation and assessment, issues regarding the reform and reform implementation. A typical type of response alternatives were 5-point likert scale. Some other appropriate scaling was also used as well as open questions.  

The analysis of the quantitative data has been performed with the SPSS-software, in a first step through crosstab analysis. The questions analysed in this paper regard sources of support for assessment and principals’ use of these sources.

 

Findings

The analysis focused firstly on internal resources for assessment such as degrees from the national school leadership programme, experience of evaluating work performance from other professions etc.

Secondly, outside support included interpersonal resources such as (a)school owner/administrative level, (b)fellow principals, (c)the NQTs appointed mentors, (d)teacher staff; and material resources such as (e)national/local competence profiles.

The analysis of support indicated, for instance, that 69% of the principals reported low or no support from owner/administrative level in the assessment of the NQTs, that is, the management of the public or private school. 71% of the principals did not cooperate with other principals regarding the design of the assessment, while 7% say that they did, to a high or very high degree.

A slightly higher proportion of support (10%) from fellow principals was reported regarding the actual assessment practice, a higher proportion of support (36%) from school staff and the highest (69%) from experienced mentors.

12% of the principals report some form of training in assessment, which can be related to the fact that 40% of principals report that they, to a very high degree, report sufficient knowledge of conducting lesson observations, which is mandated in the assessment.

No significant differences appear when data is related to principals’ gender or type of school (private or public). In sum, principals receive most support from their employees, which makes them which makes their assessment practice largely free from external control, for good or bad. The issue will be analyzed further.

In terms of TRR, the centrally distributed competency profiles seem to be of relatively low use for assessment support in comparison to local collaboration with employees. This is an example of how policy becomes enacted rather than implemented, (cf. Ball et al, 2012) depending on principals’ local work conditions and organization.

References (max 400 ord)

Ball, S. J., Maguire, M., & Braun, A. (2012). How Schools Do Policy: Policy Enactments in Secondary Schools London & New York: Routledge.

Day, C. (2000). Leading schools in times of change. Buckingham: Open Univ. Press.

Federici, R. A. (2013). Principals’ self-efficacy: relations with job autonomy,

job satisfaction, and contextual constraints. European Journal of Psychology of Education, 28:73–86

Government bill 2010/11:20 Legitimation för lärare och förskollärare [Registration for Teachers and Pre-School Teachers]. The Swedish Government.

Kimball, S.E. & Milanowski, A. (2009). Examining Teacher Evaluation Validity and Leadership Decision Making Within a Standards-Based Evaluation System. Educational Administration Quarterly. Vol. 45. No. 1. February 2009. 34–70.

Lingard, B. (2010). Policy Borrowing, Policy Learning: Testing Times in Australian Schooling, Critical Studies in Education, 51(2), 129-147

Nihlfors, E. & Johansson, O. (2013). Rektor - en stark länk i styrningen av skolan. [The Principal – a strong link in the Governance of School]. Stockholm: SNS förlag.

Swedish School Inspectorate (2010). Rektors ledarskap. En granskning av hur rektorer leder skolans arbete mot ökad måluppfyllelse. [The Principals Leadership. Inspection of how priciplas leads the schools towards increased goal-fullfilment]. Skolinspektionen: Stockholm.

SOU. 2008. Legitimation och skärpta behörighetsregler [Swedish Government Official

Report 2008:52. Registration and stricter qualifying rules]. Stockholm: Ministry of

Education and Research.

Swedish Work Environment Authority (2011). Rektorers arbetsmiljö. En tillsynsinsats genomförd av Arbetsmiljöverket (AV), distriktet i Göteborg under 2009 och 2010. [Principals working condition. An inspection by the Swedish Work Environment Authority, Gothenburg region 2009-2010] ISG 2011/100102. Göteborg: Arbetsmiljöverket.

Swedish Research Council (2011). Rektor – En forskningsöversikt 2000-2010. [Principals – a Research overview 2000-2010]. Vetenskapsrådets rapportserie. 2011:4. Stockholm: Vetenskapsrådet.

Törnsén, M. & Ärlestig, H. (red.) (2014). Ledarskap i centrum: om rektor och förskolechef. [Leadership in the center: about principals and pre-school managers]. Malmö: Gleerup.

Waldow, F. (2009). Undeclared imports: silent borrowing in educational policy-making and research in Sweden, Comparative Education Vol. 45, No. 4, November 2009, 477–494.

Keywords
School development, teacher assessment, principal, working condition
National Category
Didactics
Identifiers
urn:nbn:se:hig:diva-19164 (URN)
Conference
ECER 2015, The European Conference on Educational Research, 'Education and Transition - Contributions from Educational Research', 8-11 september 2015, Corvinus University, Budapest, Bulgarien
Funder
AFA Insurance, 120292
Available from: 2015-04-02 Created: 2015-04-02 Last updated: 2025-10-02Bibliographically approved
Fransson, G. (2014). Educational culture and the impact on national mentoring approaches: Comparing issues of trust, research-based development and ideology in a Finnish and Swedish educational context. In: AERA conference, digital database: . Paper presented at Paper presented at The American Educational Research Association (AERA) annual meeting, 3-7 April, 2014, Philadelphia, USA..
Open this publication in new window or tab >>Educational culture and the impact on national mentoring approaches: Comparing issues of trust, research-based development and ideology in a Finnish and Swedish educational context
2014 (English)In: AERA conference, digital database, 2014Conference paper, Oral presentation with published abstract (Refereed)
Abstract [en]

The purpose of this analytical paper is to examine how culturally embedded norms, values, relations and prerequisites operate in the development of a mentoring system. This is done by comparing Sweden’s top-down mandatory one-to-one mentoring approach and evaluation, with Finland’s bottom-up peer-group mentoring approach initiated, piloted and implemented by researchers. The analysis is based on meta-analysis of research, policy documents, written and oral information.

The analysis show that culturally embedded issues, such as a culture of trust, an ideology of distrust, teachers’ and researchers’ positions and the ‘need’ to strengthen cooperation or evaluate teachers in different ways, contribute to the development of peer-group mentoring and one-to-one mentoring with evaluation. 

Keywords
Comparative studies, Culture, Finland, Induction program, Mentoring, policy, Sweden, Komparativa studier, kultur, Finland, Induction, Mentorskap, policy, Sverige
National Category
Educational Sciences Pedagogy Didactics
Identifiers
urn:nbn:se:hig:diva-15680 (URN)
Conference
Paper presented at The American Educational Research Association (AERA) annual meeting, 3-7 April, 2014, Philadelphia, USA.
Funder
AFA Insurance, dnr: 120292
Available from: 2013-11-04 Created: 2013-11-04 Last updated: 2025-10-02Bibliographically approved
Fransson, G., Frelin, A. & Grannäs, J. (2014). Exploring a conceptual framework for research on Induction and Mentoring: Combining Policy enactment, task perception, and agency. In: AERA conference, digital database: . Paper presented at Paper presented at The American Educational Research Association (AERA) annual meeting, 3-7 April, 2014, Philadelphia, USA..
Open this publication in new window or tab >>Exploring a conceptual framework for research on Induction and Mentoring: Combining Policy enactment, task perception, and agency
2014 (English)In: AERA conference, digital database, 2014Conference paper, Oral presentation with published abstract (Refereed)
Abstract [en]

This paper focuses on the research questions that are emerging from the current reforms with consequences for Induction and Mentoring in various countries. The implementation focus is on the interplay between the new triad formed as a consequence of a Teacher Registration Reform in Sweden: head teacher/mentor/mentee as situated in a larger context of policy development and development in/of practice. The objective of this paper is twofold; (a) to elaborate and discuss a conceptual framework based on an interplay between the theoretical contributions of policy enactment (Ball, Maguire & Braun, 2012), task perception (Kelchtermans, 2009) and agency (Priestley and Biesta); (b) to discuss its possibilities for research within the field of induction and mentoring, and (c) provide an example of how it could be implemented in a study on induction and mentoring.

Keywords
Agency, Mentoring, policy enactment, Task perception, Teacher Induction, Teacher registration
National Category
Educational Sciences Didactics Pedagogy
Identifiers
urn:nbn:se:hig:diva-15678 (URN)
Conference
Paper presented at The American Educational Research Association (AERA) annual meeting, 3-7 April, 2014, Philadelphia, USA.
Funder
AFA Insurance, dnr:120292
Available from: 2013-11-04 Created: 2013-11-04 Last updated: 2025-10-02Bibliographically approved
Principal InvestigatorFransson, Göran
Coordinating organisation
University of Gävle
Funder
Period
2013-01-01 - 2016-12-31
National Category
Educational Sciences
Identifiers
DiVA, id: project:2216Project, id: 120292

Search in DiVA

Educational Sciences

Search outside of DiVA

GoogleGoogle Scholar