Reinforced concrete corbels were examined in this study for the cracking behavior and strength evaluation, focusing on defects typically found in these structures. A total of 11 corbel specimens were tested, including healthy specimens (HS), specimens with lower concrete strength (LC), specimens with less reinforcement ratio (LR), and specimens with more concrete cover than specifications (MC). The HS specimens were designed using the ACI conventional method. The specimens were tested under static loading conditions, and the actual strengths along with the crack patterns were determined. In the experimental tests, the shear capacity of the HS specimens was 28.18% and 57.95% higher than the LR and LC specimens, respectively. Similarly, the moment capacity of the HS specimens was 25% and 57.52% greater than the LR and LC specimens, respectively. However, in the case of the built-up sections, the shear capacity of the HS specimens was 9.91% and 37.51% higher than the LR and LC specimens, respectively. Likewise, the moment capacity of the HS specimens was 39.91% and 14.30% higher than the LR and LC specimens, respectively. Moreover, a detailed nonlinear finite element model (FEM) was developed using ABAQUS, and a more user-friendly strut and tie model (STM) was investigated toward its suitability to assess the strengths of the corbels with construction defects. The results from FEM and STM were compared. It was found that the FEM results were in close agreement with their experimental counterparts.